This year for Mother's Day my wife hinted at wanting an iPod or something similar. She liked the 2GB iPod Nano's we bought our daughters this past Christmas. However, she wanted a FM radio in order to be able to listen to the Boston Red Sox baseball games. She is a very loyal fan. Since iPods do not come with FM receivers (I know there are many add-ons available) and the iPod's cost more than what my wife would have preferred me to spend I looked for an alternative.
I think I found a winner with the Sony Network Walkman MP3 player. More specifically the NW-E005F model. It is not much larger than a USB Flash drive and it doe snot cost more, maybe even less and you can stil use for transferring files if you have space. Circuit City had it on sell for $60 - $90 less than the 2 GB Nano. The features include:
- Rechargeable Lithium-ion battery that should be good for 28 hours on an hour charge.
- It features a rapid charge mode where 3 minutes provides 3 hours of playback. To charge it just plug it into a USB port.
- A built-in high speed USB 2.0 plug under a removable cap.
- It plays back MP3, WMA, ATRAC and AAC. AAC support is only for tracks that you ripped from a CD in iTunes, not for DRM protected files you purchase online, unless they are recently purchased from the EMI label.
- It includes a option to change the menu orientation for left-handed users which my wife appreciated because she is left-handed.
- There is a scrolling single line OLED (Organic LED) display.
- The FM receiver offers 30 programmable presets, but how to do so is not intuitive.
This brings me to some of the negatives, some of which could have been avoided if Sony's engineers and programmers talked to one another. The hardware guys designed a pretty awesome player in most respects, but the software guys messed things up.
First, in order in copy music to the player you must use Sony's cumbersome SonicStage software. I have not read about anyone who likes the software. Why is software even required? I would like to simply be able to drag and drop the files and folders into the drive and have the player be able to display the artists, albums and songs. Sony uses some sort of directory encryption scheme to encode the songs. The software only works with Windows, but I do not have A Windows computer at home. I have a Mac and a couple machines running Ubuntu Linux. Fortunately, I discovered a free Java program that allows you to be able to transfer your MP3 files from your Mac or Linux computer to the Sony player. Unfortunately, the program uses Java 1.5 which is available on Mac OS 10.4 Tiger, but not on OS X 10.3 Panther which includes Java 1.4. There is no way to update it because Apple does not supply a newer version. A situation which is out the control of Sun, the creator of Java. If you want the latest version of Java you have to upgrade to the latest version of Mac OS X even if Panther offers everything you want. I found that annoying. Never the less, I was able to copy the songs to another computer and transfer them.
I find it odd that a freelance programmer could write a simple multi-platform utility and give it away for free, whereas, Sony, a multi-billion dollar corporation could only produce the awkward Windows only SonicStage, which is now past version 4 but still needs a lot of improvement.
The Hold switch and Volume controls are on the back of the device which is kind of awkward. The ear pods sound a little hollow and could be replaced with a better pair, but given the price of the player what do you want?
Overall, my wife enjoys the player despite it's quirks. The iPod wins hands down as far as ease of use, both in the player and in the iTunes software. Why Sony does not learn from the competition I do not know, because if they did then they could give the iPod Nano and the iPod Shuffle a real challenge beyond price. They player is available in different sizes and colors.